I was asked to comment on the recent documentary by MSNBC of Teen Mania’s Honor Academy by the ORU school newspaper “The Oracle”. Here are the questions they asked me and here are my responses.
I’m publishing my answers here first because I don’t trust journalists. Even ORU journalists.
1. What is your connection to Teen Mania Ministries?
I spent 3 years (August 2006- August 2009) at Teen Mania’s Honor Academy. The first year was in the basic “internship” program when I worked for the Global Expeditions call center. I spent my time at work calling students who had expressed interest in going on a mission trip with GE. I spent the remaining 2 years in the Core Advisor program. This consisted of leading, mentoring and teaching a group of first year interns though out their time at Teen Mania. I have been on 4 different mission trips with TM to Russia (’03), Botswana (’04), India (’07), and Alaska (’09).
As of now, I have very little connection with Teen Mania. Since graduating from the program in 2009 I have been to a few Acquire the Fire conventions but have not done much involving Teen Mania.
2. What was the purpose of your being there and what did you get out of your time at Teen Mania?
My original intent for going to the Honor Academy was to spend a year learning about and getting closer to God however I could while also serving God though participation in the ministry of Teen Mania.
My first year there I was able to come to grips with some very difficult things that had happened to me early in my life. I learned that the things that all the bad things that I had been through were not God’s purpose nor were they my fault entirely. After being able to let some things go, forgive myself and forgive others for those things I was finally able to pursue God in a way that I never thought possible. I was able to gain more understanding from the Bible, relate to and understand teachings more clearly both within the HA and at my home church in Texas, and gain insight into what God’s plan might be for me in my life.
The remaining two years, as a Core Advisor, I was able to help other interns along the same journey to the best of my ability. There were times during these two years that were my hardest and I failed at being a good leader more than once. But these times most often led me to understand my need for the leadership of Christ in my life more deeply and caused me to seek Jesus more fervently. Even during the times I disagreed with Teen Mania I was able to learn from my thoughts. I was always able to go to someone in leadership, either a Dorm Director or someone in leadership of my program with my doubts or disagreements. They did not try to shut me down or simply tell me that I was wrong. They listened, pointed out the holes in my logic at times, pointed me to scripture, or sometimes we even greed to disagree.
There were things about the Honor Code there that I disagreed with but I knew that I was making a commitment only for the time I was there and not for the rest of my life. If I wanted to follow those specific principles forever was my choice and through my time at the Honor Academy I was able to reason out my stances on a lot of issues such as drinking, divorce, doctrine and many other things, both by myself and with help from mentors and teachers.
3. Have you seen the story “Mind over Mania” that MSNBC put out?
Yes
4. If so, what was your response to it?
At first, it made me angry but then I gave it some more thought and I can understand some of the pain that these girls were feeling. However, even though I can understand where they are coming from, I don’t agree. Yes, there are similarities between Teen Mania and a cult BUT I feel there are many good things that come out of a time devoted to serving the Lord and pursuing him. Sure, some of Teen Mania’s way of doing things seem extreme but the purpose behind all the Life Transforming Events (LTEs) and even every day life at TM are designed to help each participant know God and themselves more fully.
One of the main things that made my experiences at Teen Mania good was that I always had friends that I could reach out to, both my peers and people in leadership. I’m naturally a loner so for a while it was difficult for me to reach out to other people. Yes, there are strict consequences for breaking the Honor Code, which I learned in my own way, but the point of the Honor Code is to create an environment most conducive to seeking God and knowing him more.
5. Do you feel that there were any points addressed in the documentary that did or did not reflect your experience while at Teen Mania? Can you give examples of each?
Yes. The most used clips were that of an LTE called ESOAL (Emotionally Stretching Opportunity of a Lifetime). During these 3-4 days, each participant (and no one is required to go through ESOAL) is pushed to their physical and emotional limit. The point is to come to the end of yourself and allow God to show you what you are capable of with him. I participated in this event 3 times and was able to discover truths about myself and God which I still regularly remember and treasure. However, from the documentary, they show so many clips of ESOAL that it looks like that is the main part of the internship when it is really only 3-4 days our of an entire year.
Secondly, they tell about these 8 signs of brainwashing but completely neglect to show how any of the scriptures that Teen Mania uses (such as “beat my body” 1 Corinthians 9:27) are in fact Biblical. Teen Mania utilizes such scriptures to show the necessity for a Christian to live not by the whims and wishes of their body but instead to be obedient to God and to be sensitive to the Holy Spirit.
One of my loved ones once accused me of being “brainwashed” by the Honor Academy. However, the Bible tells us to “renew our minds” (Romans 12:2) and to not compromise with worldly things. This is the truth TM seeks to convey and they do it very effectively. Some might say that their efforts are overzealous but it was what I needed to begin to gain control over my body and seek first the Kingdom of God. They take scripture literally and form the program accordingly.
I think these two things sum up my frustrations with the documentary however I feel that the whole documentary was the worst kind of journalism there is. It was constructed by putting piece-meal quotes from participants and leaders of the Honor Academy together along with somewhat disturbing images from a small part of the program together to make Teen Mania look like some crazy Christian boot camp. This is not true. There were no interviews with graduates from the program who think that Teen Mania was a valuable life experience such as myself or many of my friends.
6 . Do you know of any responses that have taken place as a result of the feature?
There are few responses that I know of. First is that many alumni of the HA, including myself are trying to get more involved however they can with the ministry. Also, I know from staff members who were in the program the same year as me, that Teen Mania is rethinking and reevaluating its approaches to some issues to see if change is needed and are responding accordingly if they see a need.
Also, I believe that Teen Mania itself is putting together its own documentary but I have no specific details.
Final thought:
My time at Teen Mania was possibly the most formative and important 3 years of my life. Sure, there were some patterns of thought that I unlearned. The Teen Mania “bubble” inadvertently teaches you to think that many people, even other Christians don’t understand the crisis that the world is in and are not following Jesus like they ought to. While this assumption has some merit, I learned upon leaving the HA that there are many good Christians who have never been nor will ever go to the HA and they are living a Christian life nonetheless.
However, for the most part, the habits and the ways of thinking I developed (and despite what the video says, were not forced on me) have been incredibly valuable; such as a commitment to integrity, discipline and other things.
I wouldn’t trade my time at Teen Mania for anything.